Details about my Kamailio SIP fuzzing project setup
This is the second post of a series about my Kamailio SIP fuzzing project. I will describe here my current parallel fuzzing setup in more details.
In the first post I described my motivation and shared the presentation that I did at the Kamailio World conference 2018. If you haven't read yet and don't have any fuzzing background, I would suggest you start there.
For effective fuzzing of a complex server like Kamailio you need to execute millions of test invocations. Therefore it helps a lot if you are able to use an appropriate setup with sufficient CPU and I/O power.
For my old fuzzing setup I used my home work station. This setup was of course convinient for the development, maintenance and ongoing monitoring tasks. But as I needed this machine also for other tasks this setup was somewhat limited. After my talk at Kamailio World 2018 I discussed with Fred Posner, who wanted to sponser this project. He provided me a dedicated virtual server instance, which was really great.
The new fuzzing setup is a medium sized virtual server hosted privately with Debian Linux. I setup a parallel afl fuzzing with one master instance and two to three slave instances. The master control the several slave instances. If one of the different instances finds a new execution path or a crash in the tested program, this information is periodically replicated to all the other instances. The following picture describe the setup graphically.
For each of the thousands execution paths during the tests at least one small file is created. If an actual crash is found, the crash will also stored in a file. This files are synchronized and also re-read from the different afl instances. Therefore the fuzzing puts a lot of stress on a file system. To avoid wear-out of disks/SSDs and also to improve the performance I placed the working directory in a standard RAM disk. This RAM disk is periodically copied for backup to a normal disk.
The afl suite provides some tools to monitor the state of the parallel fuzzing instances. I use tmux to monitor the progress during a test cycle and also some other parameter (disk space, CPU and I/O load). I check daily for new crashes and analyse them with Linux development tools.
I tried as well some more advanced tools from the afl suite and some related projects. Some of them did not work in my setup (e.g. test case minimization). I will investigate some of the more advanced concurrent control tools again after my setup grows. This is probably a good idea for a third blog post in the future.
Standard afl needs to to drive the program under test from standard input. Kamailio is out of the box not able to process SIP messages from stdin. Therefore several adaptions are necessary to be able to test Kamailio successfully.
At first I choosed the standard Linux text input functions
getdelim() from the GNU C library (glibc). This functions works normally great, but where not up to the tasks to process thousands of invalid and malformed messages. As result I got after some tests thousands of
SIGABRT is commonly used by glibc and other libraries to abort the program in case of critical errors. I investigated several crashes, and glibc sended the SIGABRT in case of a detected double-free or other heap corruptions. Fortunately I could easily distingish the
SIGABRT crashes from valid
SIGSEV crashes caused from Kamailio.
In the following picture you can see the state from one of the afl slave instances during a test run. From the thousands of crashes almost every one where caused from the glibc and not from Kamailio. This shows how amazingly stable the Kamailio core is, compared to other tools and even system libraries.
After several iterations I started to get also SIGSEV crashes from the GNU C library. As my objective was not to fuzz glibc and the crashes started to fill up my working directory, I decided to create a new version of the test driver.
The new test driver uses the standard glibc function
fread() to read the messages as binary data. This makes of course much more sense, I should have used this function directely from the start. This driver has the additional benefit that it don't need an magic character as a delimiter of the SIP message anymore. It was great to get rid of this hack and getting closer to the original SIP message format. So far I did not saw any new crashes related to glibc functions.
I focus in my tests on standard SIP messages like INVITE, REGISTER or ACK against a default Kamailio configuration. I plan in the future to extend the scope to other SIP messages and also to test other Kamailio modules.
The new setup is able to execute over 8 million test execution per day. My longest run so far found and successfully tested over 47.000 different program paths in Kamailio, in total over 250 million test execution have been done. My estimate for all different tests runs until today combined would be 500 million executions.
So far I found in my research this two results:
If you are running some specific or proprietary Kamailio modules in your VoIP infrastructure and would like to harden them against attacks, please contact me. These additional tests can be easily done on my infrastructure.
If you would like to support me to make Kamailio more secure against malicious attacks, I am happy about sponsoring as well.
You can reach me by e-mail at: mail at skalatan dot de